
Jimmy Clausen could become the face of the franchise. Even if he doesn't, the Panthers made the right call by selecting him.
No one really knows how a team’s draft picks will turn out. That usually takes a few years to determine, but Panthers fans have to be excited with what we did over the past two days. For once, you can’t say that we didn’t try at the QB position in the draft. Not only did we draft Jimmy Clausen, we also took Tony Pike, a player who I really liked. Both were value picks; they went much lower than expected. I am certain that they were both the best available player on the Panthers draft board when they were picked. At QB and WR, the Panthers are taking a very similar approach to what the Jaguars did with their WR position last year. They are throwing as much as they can against the wall, and hoping that something sticks. The Jags brought in a bunch of young receivers into camp last season, and guys like Mike Sims-Walker established themselves. The Panthers will now bring Brandon LaFell, Armanti Edwards, David Gettis, Dwaynes Jarrett, and Kenny Moore into camp with the hopes that one of those guys establishes himself opposite of Steve Smith. One out of those five should step up and seize the starting spot. Otherwise, Marty Hurney needs to bring in a separate scout for WRs because what we’re currently doing clearly does not work. We’re still terribly young at QB, but we also have a bunch of young guys there. We may only carry two on the roster, with the knowledge that Edwards could take some snaps at QB during a game if needed.
The beauty of this draft was that we were able to address our needs and get some great players without diverging from our best available player strategy. The one negative was that the best available player often was not a defensive lineman. Look for the Panthers to try to address that through some veteran acquisitions around training camp time, kind of like we did last year with guys like Hollis Thomas and Tank Tyler. Here are my thoughts on our picks:
Jimmy Clausen: This was a no-brainer. Many people had him rated as a top 10 player in the draft, and he was sitting there at 48. I got some calls from friends asking what I thought about the pick since I didn’t want us to pick a QB. Hey, I never said to avoid a QB. I said don’t force a pick at QB in the second round just because you need him. I just don’t think Colt McCoy and Tim Tebow are going to be good NFL QBs. I didn’t want us to reach for either of them at 48 (Tebow turned out to be gone by then) when we had other needs. Next year is going to be a good QB class, and Moore is likely going to start this year even with Clausen and Pike on the roster. If Moore sucks, we’re likely going to have a high pick next year to use on a QB. If Moore lights it up, we won’t need a QB. Clausen, however, wasn’t a reach. He was clearly the best available player, and he happened to address a position of need.
I’m not too concerned about Clausen’s character issues. I obviously don’t want him to be a team cancer, but I don’t think that’s likely. This draft must have humbled him, but also made him hungry. I want my QBs to have a little edge. Let’s face it, most NFL QBs are egomaniacs. Dan Marino had character issues. John Elway and Eli Manning forced trades. I can’t recall Big Ben having character issues as a concern before he was drafted, and look how that turned out. I support the pick. Plus, everyone knew it was coming. John Fox is good friends with Charlie Weis. Fox even tried to make Weis his offensive coordinator when he was first hired by the Panthers.
Brandon LaFell: If he can become a Muhsin Muhammad-type player, then mission accomplished. He doesn’t seem to have lightning speed and occasionally drops the ball, but he is a big possession receiver who can block down the field.

The Next Antwaan Randle El?
Armanti Edwards: This is a great pick. I’m always hesitant about giving up a future pick, but Edwards was supposedly a stud at his pro day workout at App State. He is so versatile and can help us out in so many ways. Who says that Charlotte pro teams can only cater to the base by picking UNC guys? I like us getting an App guy. The 500 sections will be rowdy next season with the mountain folk!
Lesson learned about the draft: believe what you hear early. A lot of people had the Panthers interested in Edwards and Pike early on, but we didn’t hear about those two over the last couple of weeks. That is because teams send out tons of misinformation in the weeks leading up to the draft to confuse other teams. That may have been the case with Taylor Price. Keep in mind, the Panthers had a chance to draft Price, but they chose Edwards. The Observer even had a story about a month back on how the Panthers were really interested in Edwards, but I still fell for the Price hype. The Panthers had clearly targeted Edwards, and they got their guy.
Eric Norwood: This guy could be a heck of a steal. The Panthers are excellent at drafting LBs, so they must have really seen something they liked in Norwood. He is a little undersized, but he is a flat out football player. You can do worse than that in the 4th round. Even if he doesn’t compete for a starting job, we lost some veteran LBs, so Norwood helps out with depth.
Greg Hardy: If he doesn’t get injured every other play, then we could have a good pash rusher. He could basically play the role played by Charles Johnson the past few years. Have you noticed the Panthers are drafting for speed and talent? I like it.
David Gettis: Never heard of this guy, but let’s throw him into the WR mix.
Tony Pike: He’s 6’5″, which makes him even more of a physical presence than Clausen. A lot of the scouts tore him up during the combine and workouts. He may have arm strength issues, but I really liked what I saw out of him in college. Who knows, he may grow into a very good QB in a couple of seasons.
Jordan Pugh, R.J. Stanford, Robert McClain: The Panthers scored a late round coup last year with Captain Munnerlyn. It would be nice if one these guys provides some much-needed help at corner next season.
35.229000
-80.846000
I Don’t Understand the Pessimism
August 8, 2010 by qcsportsblog
I listened to Charlotte sports radio a good amount this past week. I rarely listen to it, so forgive me if I am describing a familiar occurence. There was hysteria amongst Panthers fans. Everyone was freaking out, hating all of our offseason moves, and basically giving up on the season…before the preseason has even started. I don’t like to give too much weight to what a bunch of Gastonians who call in on sports radio think, but this was still very disturbing. I don’t understand the pessimism. In fact, this is the most excited I have been for Panthers season in recent memory. I mean it; I’m even more excited than when we were coming off winning seasons.
The reason for my excitement is the air of change in the organization. How refreshing will it be to see the first team break the huddle with Matt Moore as its leader? How exciting will it be to see the new and young faces fighting for a multitude of roster spots? We are the youngest team in the league. Guys like Everette Brown, Bradon LaFell, Sherrod Martin, Charles Godfrey, Charles Johnson, Tony Fiammetta, and Dan Connor will be counted on to step up big this year. The next Steve Smiths and Jon Beasons are on this roster; we just have to find them and let them play. Sure, there are risks with our predicament. We could suck this year, but can’t we be excited in early August? I am excited to see how these guys handle their roles. I want to see them grow and develop into the future of this franchise.
While all the talk about the young guys is good, it’s not like our cupboard is completely bar. We still have a bunch of A-list stars. Jon Beason, Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jonathan Stewart, Jeff Otah, Jordan Gross, and Chris Gamble form a pretty solid core that a lot of teams envy. Those guys should keep us in most games (especially with an easy schedule) and should serve as great mentors to the young guys. So, with the first preseason game right around the corner, what should you look for (if you can stay awake through the entire game)?
Special Teams: The recent Charlotte Observer article said it all. Click the pull down tab on the side titled “how the mighty have fallen.” The Panthers have always have good special teams play in their winning seasons. They will need it again this year, but there is a lot of uncertainty on the special teams. Both punt return and kickoff return spots are in play. Also, keep an eye out on how Jason Baker handles kickoffs. Losing Rhys Lloyd was huge; we enjoyed a huge advantage when he constantly forced teams to start at their 20. John Fox’s style of football usually means that we will be in most games. Therefore, a big return or special teams turnover can be the key that gives us the extra boost to victory in a tight game.
Jimmy Clausen: I know it’s firmly Matt Moore’s job (and I’m glad that it is), but we haven’t had a big name QB around here in a while. We haven’t even drafted a QB in years, let alone a highly-rated one. It’s only natural to want to see him play, even if it is on second team. That may be what gets me through the second halves of these preseason games.
D-Line: Are we executing? Are we stopping the run and getting some pressure on the QB? It may be tough to tell in the preseason because most teams normally run some very vanilla plays.
Posted in Commentary | Tagged Carolina Panthers | Leave a Comment »